News & Views
Global Indian historians challenge UKs misleading citizenship test
Over 180 historians including Global Indian academics from leading universities have challenged the UK's citizenship and settlement test for being “fundamentally misleading” on issues related to slavery and the British Empire.
The signatories of an open letter to the UK Home Office include Aditya Sarkar, Associate Professor of History at the University of Warwick; Anindita Ghosh, Professor of Modern Indian History at the University of Manchester; Tirthankar Roy, Professor in Economic History, London School of Economics; Kalathmika Natarajan, Teaching Fellow in South Asian History, University of Edinburgh; Somak Biswas, Early Career Fellow, Institute of Advanced Studies/History, University of Warwick; and the bestselling author William Dalrymple, behind a series of books related to the British Empire in India, the most recent being?'The Anarchy: The Relentless Rise of the East India Company'. They have demanded a review of the history section as a “matter of urgency”.
“We are historians of Britain and the British Empire and writing in protest at the on-going misrepresentation of slavery and Empire in the 'Life in the UK Test',” notes the open letter issued in the official journal of the Historical Association.
“The official handbook published by the Home Office is fundamentally misleading and in places demonstrably false decolonisation was not an 'orderly' but an often violent process, not only in India but also in the many so-called 'emergencies' such as the Mau-Mau Uprising in Kenya (1952-1960). We call for an immediate official review of the history chapter,” it reads.
“People in the colonies and people of colour in the UK are nowhere actors in this official history. The handbook promotes the misleading view that the Empire came to an end simply because the British decided it was the right thing to do. Similarly, the abolition of slavery is treated as a British achievement, in which enslaved people themselves played no part,” it adds.
The “Life in the UK Test” is a compulsory requirement for any applicants for citizenship or “indefinite leave to remain” residency rights in the UK and the official Home Office handbook issued for its preparation covers different sections of British life, including its history. But the historians believe that people from Commonwealth countries like India and other former British colonies are not given a fair representation in the handbook.
They highlight that the book is “silent” about colonial protests, uprisings and independence movements. Applicants are expected to learn about more than 200 individuals but the only individual of colonial origin named in the book is Sake Dean Mohamet from India, who co-founded England's first curry house in 1810.
The letter highlights: “The 'Life in the UK Test' is neither a trivial quiz nor an optional discussion point. It is an official requirement in the application for settlement or citizenship and provides essential information about the United Kingdom.
“This official, mandatory version of history is a step backwards in historical knowledge and understanding. Historical knowledge is and should be an essential part of citizenship. Historical falsehood and misrepresentation, however, should not.”
The aim of the official handbook is to promote tolerance and fairness and facilitate integration but the historians fear, in its current version, the historical pages do the opposite.
"As historians we believe in debate, but interpretations of the past have to be based on facts. The distortion of the past is a challenge to democratic culture and liberal values. Historical misrepresentation should not be officially sponsored by the state,” they warn.
The Home Office said the handbook is intended only as a “starting point” to explore British history in greater detail and indicated that the contents are kept under review based on feedback.
It said in a statement: “Given the breadth of British history, the Life in the UK handbook provides a starting point to explore our past and help those seeking to live permanently in the UK gain a basic understanding of our society, culture and historical references which occur in everyday conversations.
“We have published several editions of the handbook since it was launched and will continue to keep its contents under review and consider any feedback we receive.”
by Aditi Khanna